all rise

[self_composed]

No plea bargain is struck. The jury is picked, and Lucinda asks a few random ones whether they have accepted bribes and sees who looks nervous: no one, as it turns out, so she strikes people who are too young to have children and one fellow who looks like he hates the entire world for her picks. Paul strikes a grandmotherly type and someone who admits when asked that they don't think much of rich people.

"All rise," comes the command as Judge Roberts walks in.

Comments

[self_composed]

"So," Lucinda says, "your explanation for events is that Laney broke his own ribs... somewhere... and was transported home, by someone other than you, even though you are the family's driver and were working that day... and even though an ambulance would have taken him directly to the hospital... and that none of these things struck you as potentially worth informing the police, so even when Officer Kerenksy sought you out specifically you only told him... 'dunno'. Is that right?"

[edgeofyourseat]

He opens his mouth.

He closes his mouth.

"...yes?"

[self_composed]

"That's very interesting," Lucinda says, narrowing her eyes. "I have an architectural plan here. It shows that the Hammond family's current residence was remodeled extensively before they moved in, and that among the renovations made was extensive soundproofing. In every room. This advertisement for the sale of their former residence in New York advertises similar amenities. Did you ever hear any very... very... quiet sounds - that could have been associated with violence occurring in the house, given that information?"

[edgeofyourseat]

"I have never made a habit of eavesdropping on my employers," he snaps.

[self_composed]

"I didn't ask if you listened," Lucinda says softly. "I asked if you heard."

[edgeofyourseat]

"Well, I didn't."

[self_composed]

"You are still under oath," Lucinda points out.

But if that doesn't shake anything loose, she moves on. "Assuming you were being entirely candid, would you describe Mr. Hammond, Sr., as having a temper?"

[edgeofyourseat]

"Yes," he says, reluctantly.

[self_composed]

"Have you ever heard him say, or imply, or suggest by way of demeanor, that he intended to strike his son or had done so in the past?" This is intentionally overbroad.

[edgeofyourseat]

"...I don't remember?" he tries.

[self_composed]

"Really," Lucinda says. "So you don't think that would have seemed remarkable to you, if your employer had announced that he was going to commit a violent crime? It could have slipped your mind?"

[edgeofyourseat]

"You didn't say announce, you said suggest by demeanour," he says. "How do I know what a man who's going to hit his son looks like? I've never seen anyone do it!"

[self_composed]

"I also said say and imply," Lucinda says implacably. "I'm not expecting you to be a psychologist. So," she continues, "are you saying that you do not believe that your employer ever struck his son? That seems vanishingly unlikely to you, because most people don't hit their sons and you have never seen evidence otherwise, as you've explained?"

[edgeofyourseat]

"...yes?"

[self_composed]

"You don't sound sure," Lucinda says. "Are you sure? It's all right - as long as you're sincerely sure, it's not perjury to say so."

[edgeofyourseat]

Ohhhhh boy.

"I'm... not sure... anymore," says Theo.

[self_composed]

"No?" Lucinda asks, like she's surprised. "And why is that?"

[edgeofyourseat]

He glances quickly over at Alice, who returns him an utterly flat look.

"...I've never really... thought about it like this... before."

[self_composed]

"Can you elaborate, please?" Lucinda says.

[edgeofyourseat]

This would be so much easier if Theo did not consider himself a person of integrity. But he does.

"...I tried not to think about it at all."

[self_composed]

"Think about what?" Lucinda asks.

[edgeofyourseat]

"Things that are none of my business."

He is aware as he says it how terrible it sounds.

[self_composed]

"Well, now that you're thinking about it, please tell us about any evidence you may have seen regarding the allegations at hand," Lucinda says.

[Is he always this cagey?] Bella asks Alice.

[edgeofyourseat]

[He hates telling anybody anything about anybody else. I'm half sure he used to work for a family a lot shadier than mine.]

"I didn't... notice anything," says Theo, with great difficulty. "Nothing specific. Nothing that stood out."

[self_composed]

"Then why are you so unsure about whether your employer could have been abusing his son? Please, explain," Lucinda says.

[She is being way more patient than I would,] Bella remarks.